|
|
||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Cramming It In
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 2.1 | Company/Technology/Product | NIST GCR 99-779 |
Make it
easy for people to quickly understand what you sell.
For example, describe your anti-corrosive material for
metallic parts as undercoating or your database
tool as being like the library book indexing system. These
analogies help people visualize what your company does
and why customers buy. This demystifies the technology
and allows investors (who are largely market and financially
oriented) to see a path to making money with your technology.
It is even more effective if the analogy you cite is
a consumer experience to which everyone in the room can
personally relate (e.g., the pain of slow Internet service
or the cost of car tires that wear out too fast). Analogies
also are a powerful tool for your 1-minute elevator
pitch.
Tell the audience why you started (or joined) the company. This strategy offers you a great chance to tell a story, but make sure it sends a message that they care about. For example, say: With 21 years of experience in this industry, I knew this problem had to be fixed. The only question was who would come up with a cost-effective solution. Or: A former customer convinced me to turn this idea into a business, and he said he would be the first to buy. Or: The founders have teamed up before on other successful projects and we work very well together.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.4 | Complex Strategies for Rich Technology Platforms | NIST GCR 99-779 |
List on a single slide or verbally state five to eight meaningful accomplishments your company has achieved. Especially effective are technical milestones that show commercial viability, beta tests or customer trials, interested current investors, a strong management team and board, and corporate partnerships. Also include any awards you have received for your product/technology from publications or at tradeshows. These achievements show progress and also give investors confidence that you will do good things with their money.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 2.3 | Goals and Objectives | NIST GCR 99-779 |
Investors
will grant you the benefit of the doubt and assume that
your technology works, especially in the first screening
meeting. So just give them an overview of the technology,
the product, and your intellectual property position.
In a 20-minute pitch these items should take up no more
than about 8 minutes. There will be plenty of time later
for technical due diligence. Also, investors already
know you are smart and have technical experts, so you
dont have to try to impress them with your knowledge.
They want to hear why people will buy, how quickly your
start-up can become profitable, if your product can be
implemented in a large-scale fashion at a reasonable
price, and the status of your competition.
If you
dont have any actual sales revenue, you have to
present feedback from potential customers about your
product. Mock up a demo or produce a data sheet, and
attach some price ranges, so that the feedback will better
reflect customers actual interest in purchasing
or licensing what you sell. Try to have some performance
data of an early prototype to show to investors. For
example, show samples of images given to you by potential
customers and how your image enhancement software significantly
improved their images. Tell investors what positive comments
you have gotten from end users, original equipment manufacturers,
and distribution channels. Hopefully, these companies
also will serve as references that you can give to investors
to assist them in due diligence.
In addition,
investors need to know how much money you want, what
you will use it for, and what is a realistic exit path
to cash out. With respect to exit strategy, dont
just say you could either go public or get acquired.
If you can justify an initial public offering (revenue,
market interest, existing public companies similar to
yours) then great. But if the realistic exit scenario
is acquisition, then say that is the likely strategy.
Cite examples of potential acquirers. Explain why you
can leverage the value of the acquiring company. And
mention any representative acquisitions that have occurred
in your industry and the size of the deal.
If you
have to cut any part of your presentation, make it the
technical portion. Investors already know your technology
works, or at least they grant you that in your first
presentation. Plus, they know the due diligence will
reveal any major concerns. In fact, talking too much
about the technology could backfire and confuse them
about your business. And lack of understanding will quickly
lead them to say no.
You also
need to know what other investments the venture capitalist
or corporate
partner has made that are in your same market space. To attract
investors, especially in economic downturns such as we experienced
in 2001, it is also helpful if your technology or channel strategy
can bring leverage to one of their existing portfolio investments.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.7 | Equity Investments | NIST GCR 99-779 |
Remember
that investors are very numbers-oriented people, especially
with respect to financial and operational information.
Too often, entrepreneurs assume that throwing in some
huge multibillion dollar market projection is sufficient
to impress investors. But it is far more important to
include financial data about your cash flow, burn rate,
staffing, revenue expectations, breakeven date, funding
secured, funding being sought, and how the money will
be used.
Dont
try to make your numbers conservative or aggressive.
For one thing, investors
are fed up with hearing start-ups claim: These are very
conservative estimates! Simply present the best realistic
projections that you can defend. Finally, dont fret over
getting the financials perfect. Unfortunately, investors dont
really believe your projections anyway. What really matters is
whether your business model makes sense and your assumptions
behind the numbers.
Do not ever preface what you say with an excuse. It is astounding how often an entrepreneur will begin a presentation with a statement such as: I dont feel very well or My flight got in late or I didnt have much time to prepare or The prototype is not quite ready. Beginning the presentation that way makes you look unprofessional and indicates to the audience that you dont regard them as being worthy of your best effort. And whatever you do, dont imply that something is their fault, for example: Gee, the lights in here are pretty bad or We didnt know all of you would be here.
Do not
ignore the need to continuously read your audience as
you present. To begin, ask the people in the room who
they are and what their role is in the investment firm
or the corporation you are meeting with. This will sensitize
you as to what is important to them personally. Then
your pitch becomes more of you talking directly with
individuals (i.e., connecting with real people) and not
just to some anonymous group of faceless people.
Entrepreneurs
often get so transfixed on what they are presenting that
they forget to really look at the people in the room.
It is insufficient to simply make eye contact. The art
of telling your story includes listening to your audience
even when they are not speaking. You can monitor how
you are being received by whether they nod their heads,
take notes, keep their eyes fixed on you, ask questions,
interact with your props or demo, give you supporting
comments, laugh, or respond to the questions you ask.
What is the climate and energy level of the room? By
being ever aware of these signals, almost subconsciously
aware, you will be able to spontaneously adjust to keep
the audience interested and actively involved. Adjusting
as you go will ensure you are turning them on, not off.
Think of
your slides as being Cliffs Notes (i.e., reminders of
what you are going to discuss). You must never read your
slides to the audience! Even if you put a lengthy quote
from a customer on a slide, do not read it. It is insulting
to your audience and it also removes a great opportunity
for them to be actively involved. The goal is to have
them participate. You want them to be part of your story
so that they become part of your team. If done right,
investors will actually look for ways to help you during
the meeting.
A common
mistake most people make when presenting slides or overheads
is to allow the sequence of the slides to dictate what
you say and when. This is a problem, for example, when
an investor interrupts you and forces you to cover something
you planned to cover later. Yet, when you come to the
slide covering that point 8 minutes later you still force
everyone to listen to the same information again. Presenters
try to excuse it by saying, I know we already covered
this, but I want to repeat it because its important. Skip
it if you can or use it in your closing summary. It frees
up time for you to cover other material and also gives
your audience a break from redundancy. If you really
did not cover the point sufficiently when you were interrupted,
then focus just on the key missing aspects.
Another
approach to handling questions and interruptions is to
know your slides so well that you can quickly go to the
particular slide that addresses the question. This also
means not having so many slides that you lose track.
In addition to showing your ability to think on your
feet, being able to jump to another slide makes the audience
feel involved. It shows that you respect their input.
Be thankful if an investor is interested enough to ask
you a question. The home run in this sort of interruption
is when the audience actively jumps in and tries to come
up with solutions and ideas to address the technical
or market issue. But this can never happen if you are
blindly running through your presentation because you
have slides you have to get through.
If you
are trying to cover too many slides or you are allowing
the order of the slides to dictate what you say and when,
you are guilty of letting the tail (your slides) wag
the dog (you the storyteller).
One of
the worst situations is when it is obvious that a presenter
is trying to cram slides into a limited time frame. It
also indicates that the presenter is less prepared. When
you start rushing or being held to your artificial goal
of having to get through every slide, you look uncomfortable
and less confident. And if you feel uncomfortable and
less confident, your audience will feel the same way
about you.
Remember
that your goal is to tell a story by providing an interactive,
fun experience that people will remember. The goal is
not to do a one-way lecture that people have to survive
through.
When you
present, the room is yours! Even if the investors set
it up, you can change some things, including the lighting,
the area in front and sides of the room for you to move
around, the wires for the projector that might trip you,
where water is for you to drink, a whiteboard or easel
in case you need it, and closing room doors to minimize
outside distractions.
You must
not view a presentation to investors as if you are on
trial in front of a jury. Instead, you should view yourself
as being on the same side as the investors and trying
to come up with the best approach to making money together.
That viewpoint also means you must acknowledge investors concerns
and questions and follow up later to address any issues
that need extra work. If you view prospective investors
as teammates and not as them, you will be
more effective and you also will have more fun in your
business.
In keeping
with one of the basic tenets of being a powerful storyteller,
namely control the room, you have every right
to adjust the lighting however you wish. Most rooms will
have a set of various ceiling lights and dimmer settings.
Projectors today have sufficient backlighting to allow
slides to be visible even in a fully lit room. Its
best if you can slightly turn down, but not off, the
lights directly over the screen, which will provide sufficient
contrast for your slides without putting you in a dark
spot. Make sure the audience can see you clearly. Since
you do not know what to expect when you walk into a venture
capital or corporate conference room, design and test
your slides to be visible and attractive even in well-lit
rooms. One way to do this is to use darker backgrounds.
Finally, be sure not to turn down the lights that are over the audience. You need to be able to see everyone and make personal eye contact and physical connections. Moreover, dark lights allow people to hide and even go to sleep, especially after lunch and in mid-afternoon.
Practice your pitch at least three times before you present to the first investor group. Practice in front of a live audience, even if it is just an audience of two staff members or friends. Better yet, videotape yourself to really find ways to improve and to build your confidence.
Given the
inevitable shakeups and realities of business, good entrepreneurs
make adjustments all the time as a natural course of
running their company. Likewise, being able to make spontaneous
adjustments in front of an audience is a powerful talent
that turns your presentation into a real story. Your
talk will come alive. Do something a bit different than
standing up in front of the room and reciting your pre-scripted
words slide by slide. But doing something different must
be for a specific purpose that fits the particular situation.
And it must reinforce your point or provide a mechanism
for you to keep control of the room. For example, here
are a few techniques that come in handy and can become
part of your storytelling style. You can choose to use
them at different times and in different presentations,
depending on how you read the audience:
These examples
are the types of moves that will make you stand out and
be remembered. But it must be for a specific purpose
that fits that situation and reinforces your point. So
dont do these things in a silly or contrived fashion.
Sometimes it will make sense to do certain things and
sometimes it wont. When you use a variety of techniques
that make your presentation and business personally engaging,
you will see the difference in how the audience reacts.
You should
present to venture capitalists and angel investors even
if you do not need or want their money. They can provide
smart insights, objective feedback, and other contacts
who can help you. Even if such investors are not interested,
they network with others and will be more likely to mention
your name if you offer a strong presentation/story. Many
entrepreneurs have raised money after being rejected
by one investor who later mentioned the company to another
interested investor. In addition to being great practice,
building a relationship with investors puts you in a
stronger position to approach them when you do need money.
Some start-ups begin meeting with venture capitalists
6 to 12 months before they actually need the money. When
they are ready, they know what to prepare for, what to
say, and which investors to target.
Seek specific
feedback from every investor presentation you give. Especially
listen to the questions they ask. Also get feedback from
your team members who attend the meeting. You should
adjust your pitch slightly (or, in some cases, greatly)
based on this feedback.
Presenting
yourself, especially when trying to raise money, requires
an intensity and focus that can easily blind you to how
you are actually coming across. Try to be objective.
Bring along a colleague whom you respect and trust. As
soon as you leave the meeting together, ask for honest
feedback and suggestions for improvement.
An additional
benefit of practicing with actual investors is that you
will quickly discover that one or two major objections
keep coming up. Such objections can be especially tricky
when your product involves a common consumer application.
For example, your technology may have something to do
with cell phones (e.g., screen size, color display, wireless
application, battery life). Everyone in the room will
be able to relate to it. While
it may be good for a common reference point, it also can backfire
because everyone sees him- or herself as an expert. One person
might decide that her personal experience with her cell phone
does not match your claim about the problem that your technology
will solve. Or another person might choose to sidetrack your
entire presentation because he doesnt personally feel the
pain you are solving. You also might get challenged just because
that makes it easier for an investor to say no before
moving on to the next deal. To avert this situation, you need
to preempt the objection by defining the segment of the market
that will buy your product. You can make this clear with market
data and user feedback or you can explain the difference between
the audience members and your target customers (e.g., field service
technicians who use cell phones versus office workers who use
cell phones).
Such a
disruption is a good opportunity to demonstrate your
ability to handle objections and difficult people. It
is a skill that investors will respect. Acknowledge the
potential concern but redirect the focus to how there
is money to be made in your business. Take back control
of your meeting. Be firm, but dont be defensive.
You also need to be reading the rest of the audience
to see if you have an ally whom you can call on to help.
Theres nothing better than when one investor partner
helps you to shut down a fellow partner or associate.
If you run into an especially aggressive disrupter, here are
three possible counter-approaches to try:
Unfortunately,
a single negative opinion can take on a life of its own
within the room. But you can short-circuit a negative
mood merely by doing something unusual and by sincerely
engaging people. It is worth taking two or three practice
runs with investors just to discover objections that
repeatedly surface. Of course, practice with investors
who are not on your prime target list. You can then design
a slide or have words ready to preempt the recurring
objection(s) for future investor meetings. Also, you
will learn how to handle difficult situations. In fact,
how you handle disruptive people can make or break the
opportunity to do a deal, and can easily outweigh the
impact of the rest of your presentation.
Go visit a classroom at your childs school and learn from some of the best storytellers in the world: teachers. They have to captivate 30 restless kids for hours in spite of all the disruptions and time pressures that exist in a classroom. See how the teacher adapts and still gets through the agenda. The best teachers engage students so they participate and do not simply throw information at them. Observe how teachers use appropriate humor and how they challenge people to think.
A wise
investor once said, The art of raising money is
the art of reducing risk. Investors and corporate
partners know there is risk in any new project, especially
when breakthrough technology is involved. Do not trivialize
the challenges. Doing so will make investors suspicious
or conclude you are naive. Tell them how their money
is going to reduce the risk and thereby increase the
likelihood that your business will succeed.
Although your business plan should include a section on risks, it not a good idea to use such a slide in your presentation. It could scare people off prematurely. Instead, to demonstrate your understanding of the business, use a challenge slide. It should list three or four primary hurdles that any company competing in your business will have to overcome. Dont limit the challenges just to what your company faces but include general industry challenges. Then you can show how your answer to each challenge is better than that of your competition and also how you will use the investors money to overcome the challenges (risks). An alternative to a slide is to verbally note the challenges and your solutions as you proceed through your pitch.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 2.4 | Challenges/Requirements/Opportunities | NIST GCR 99-779 |
It is much
quicker and less work for investors and corporate partners
to say no. So dont give them an easy
excuse to say it. Do your homework so you know what they
invest in and how they operate. Learn the economics of
the business you are targeting. And practice your story.
Have your challenge slide ready to show that you understand
the risks and that you have better solutions than your
competition.
Nonetheless,
the reality is that only a few of the 1020 investors
you present to will be interested. For some, it may have
nothing to do with you. It may turn out that their fund
is simply not a good fit for the type or stage of company
you are. Or they may not have a person available who
can act as your champion.
Qualify the investors ahead of time as much as they qualify you. Also, get the right people in the room. If you are targeting the auto industry, request that the partner in the firm who has the most experience with automotive markets be present. Otherwise, it may be best to reschedule. Too often, like many business meetings, everyone feels good coming out of the room and everyone says the right, courteous things. But without an inside champion to drive the deal, not much will happen. The good news is that most venture capitalists are assertive and straightforward people. So you will most likely know where you stand pretty fast.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.7 | Equity Investments | NIST GCR 99-779 |
You are looking for teammates in investors and corporate partners. Even if they criticize, dont allow yourself to feel like you are on trial. Show respect and acknowledge that you need their help their expertise, contacts, and money. Listen to their questions and answer them directly and honestly. If they are sincere in wanting to work with you they will help to answer some of your companys challenges instead of beating you up with them. If all they want to do is tell you why you wont succeed or whats wrong with your plan, then say thanks and leave. Read your audience and get them involved. Youll be able to determine sooner if there is sincere interest. Ask specifically what it will take for them to invest. Youll save yourself time and keep yourself from having false hope.
Selecting
investors is a two-way street. Just like investors aggressively
screen you and conduct due diligence before committing
to your company, you have the right to ask them specific
questions. Ask about their current companies the
value they have brought, partnering deals they helped
make happen, and strategic planning support. What is
their investment philosophy, criteria, and decision process?
Talk with a few of their portfolio companies and get
opinions from other professionals such as law firms and
venture capitalists who have worked with them.
You can also keep the playing field level by having other investors on your list. Finally, have a backup plan to minimize your cash burn rate. Then you can wait for a good deal instead of feeling pressured to take the first one that comes along.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.6 | Teaming for Success | NIST GCR 99-779 |
Putting your best foot forward is an essential mindset to adopt when you are presenting (or negotiating a deal). There is no need to make excuses for what you dont have. Investors and large companies know you dont have all the pieces in place. They will accept deficiencies as long as you can convince them that you do have (and own) something that can make them money.
Move during
your presentation. Use hand and arm gestures, stroll
around, point to an easel, lean over the back of a chair,
and hand your audience a product sample. Movement shows
energy and confidence and it gets people interested.
It also forces investors to focus on you, not on your
slides. If you are more comfortable with small steps
and fewer arm movements, thats fine. Just dont
be a statue. Roam around the front of the room a bit
and make sustained eye contact (35 seconds).
One way
to really stand out and get their attention is to physically
approach the audience and ask for a prop. Using one of
their personal cell phones, personal digital assistants,
watches, or coffee cups is a compelling way to tell a
story by showing how your technology is used by everyday
people. This strategy will help you redirect your audience
from being passive bystanders into active participants.
They will better understand what and why customers will
buy.
Why do
so few people smile when they present in front of an
audience? It may seem like a small thing, but smiling
is extremely powerful. Not only will you stand out because
few people do it, but it also will loosen you up and
make the presentation a more pleasant experience for
everyone. If you are clearly enjoying yourself, then
it is a near certainty that the investors will as well.
Remember: What they think of you and what it would
be like to work with you greatly impacts what
they think of your business.
Even if
speaking and moving with some energy is not your style,
you need to do it. That doesnt mean you force yourself
to become something you are not or to act crazy. But
think about it . . . You love what you do and believe
your technology can really make a difference. You spend
many hours (years) at it and have sacrificed a lot. So
it should be easy, and even natural, for you to share
some of that energy and passion. Share it to the degree
and in a way you are comfortable with. You might start
by simply speaking louder and with more conviction at
key points in your story. You could cross in front of
the room a couple times and get close to a couple of
people and make direct eye contact with them. Or you
can lean in toward your audience and make a fist a few
times as you express some feeling about the great progress
your company is making.
Dont
think that speaking fast or showing enthusiasm indicates
a lack of substance or knowledge. While being a high-energy
or low-energy person is often a reflection of personality,
the fact remains that YOU are what the audience sees.
And since on the order of 60 percent of an investors
decision is based on you and your team, you need to impress
them with what they see as well as with what they can
read about you. Your knowledge and background are important.
But it also takes a huge amount of energy to grow a successful
start-up.
Knowledge.
Experience. Energy. Investors want it all! Wouldnt
you? Try to be objective, and ask yourself, Would
I invest in this person and in this business?
If you ever find yourself presenting for 30 minutes without two or three moments of laughter with the audience, then you need to lighten up. It is human nature to seek out pleasure. As evidence, studies show that 40 percent of the reason people attend seminars and workshops is to be entertained. A little levity also will relax you and allow you more control of the meeting.
Dont
try to be a standup comic or use canned jokes. The best
kind of humor for entrepreneurs comes up spontaneously
as part of the natural flow of things. This need for
spontaneity is another reason it is so important to involve
the audience. They will always give you opportunities
to respond with something a bit funny.
Another key to adding humor to your pitch is to take what you do seriously but dont take yourself too seriously. So dont be afraid to interject personal things where you live, a little bit about your family, sports, or what you did last week. In addition to getting people to remember you, know you, and like you, sharing personal tidbits can provide great moments for humor and fun.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.2 | A Financing Primer | NIST GCR 99-779 |
Most venture capitalists dont have the time or need to read a business plan before deciding whether it is worth talking with you. So you have to provide them a snapshot of your business in less than 510 minutes. Use a strong two- to three-paragraph introductory e-mail (ideally with a reference to someone they know) and attach an Executive Summary and a business-oriented PowerPoint presentation with 1020 slides. Keep the graphics simplified for faster and easier e-mailing. A great side benefit of this e-mail package is it makes it easy for investors to pass it on to others who may be interested.
If you
want a surefire way to stand out in the crowd, develop
a great closing for your pitch. The vast
majority of entrepreneurs end their presentations with
mundane statements such as: Thank you, well
be happy to answer any questions you have or We
have a booth set up, so feel free to drop by. Youd
be amazed how often the presenter simply stops talking
and people in the audience look around the room wondering
if they are done. It also is a common mistake to close
by tailing off with a softening voice and declining energy
level. Would such an ending make you jump up and write
a check?
If you
want to inspire people to work with you, give them something
to grab onto. Give them something to think about that
will make them want to run and find you in the hallway
after you leave. Just like selling a product, raising
money is an iterative process. Every contact with the
investor or corporate partner is a mini-sales cycle with
an opportunity for you to close that phase of the process
(e.g., first meeting, initial due diligence, second meeting,
term sheet, etc.) Your goal is to get the investor to
say, Tell me more. Effective closings include
the following:
We
are in the process of selecting three investment partners
to work with, and plan to complete this selection by
early December. We have one already committed (say name
if can) and believe you would be very valuable because
of your (fill in what they bring that you want besides
money). What will it take to get you to join us?
We
would like to work with you because you understand why
solving the (fill in) problem is important, and because
you can reach the customers. Leveraging our product through
your current sales channels could add over X million
dollars a year in profitability to your division.
Jack
(mention your contact/coach by name) has been very helpful
in defining how our technology and your product fit together.
Who would be the best person to work with to structure
our business relationship? Or what would be the best
way to proceed from here?
An effective closing assumes that you have already:
Finally, if you do nothing else, inject some passion and energy into your closing.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.7 | Equity Investments | NIST GCR 99-779 |
A great
benefit of learning the art of telling your story is
that you will be a more effective negotiator and will
close more deals. Entrepreneurs who can sign up major
customers, licensing partners, and investors will succeed.
Because a negotiation is a relationship, it demands a
strong ability to connect with people. You need to apply
the same skills you use when you present to an audience:
Read people. Get information. See things from their perspective.
All of these skills, which improve as you make presentations,
are essential to making deals.
Just as we discussed that a presentation is not me versus them, you will come to view the people you are negotiating with as being part of your team. Whether they are an investor, customer, corporate partner, or distributor, the teams goal becomes finding a way to make money together. It is not for you to try to sell or convince them. Put your best foot forward, but always keep an eye on addressing their needs and concerns. You will communicate better and get people to believe in your business and want to work with you.
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.5 | Licensing | NIST GCR 99-779 |
| ATP Commercialization Guide | Section 1.6 | Teaming for Success | NIST GCR 99-779 |
Go to Chapter 4 or return to Table of Contents
Date created:
May 24, 2002
Last updated:
August 2, 2005
ATP website comments: webmaster-atp@nist.gov / Technical ATP inquiries: InfoCoord.ATP@nist.gov. NIST is an agency of the U.S. Commerce Department |